Skip to content

Top 10 Fall Fundraising Items, Ranked by Real Orders

By Hoosier Boy Fundraising · Updated · 5 min read

If your group is deciding what to sell this fall, the best guide is what customers actually buy. This list comes from real orders: every plant sold through the more than 100 Indiana school, church, sports and community fundraisers we supplied in fall 2026.

Garden mums dominate. They made up about four of every five plants ordered, and five mum colors made the top 10. A few other items quietly sold well too, and they're worth adding to your order form.

  1. 1. Orange and bronze garden mums

    Orange garden mum in full bloom in a 9-inch pot

    The clear winner, outselling white mums nearly three to one. Orange and bronze are the colors people picture on a fall porch, and they go with pumpkins, corn stalks and almost any front door.

    Customers rarely stopped at one. People who chose orange mums bought about two each, so a single sale is often a matched pair for the front steps.

    Tip: Put orange first on your order form and in your posts. It's the easiest yes you'll get.

  2. 2. Red garden mums

    Red garden mum in full bloom

    A close second to orange. Red reads as rich and warm, and it's the favorite second color for porches that already have orange or yellow.

    Orange and red together made up more than half of every mum sold.

  3. 3. Yellow garden mums

    Yellow garden mum in full bloom

    Outsold white about two to one. Yellow is the bright, cheerful option, and it shows up from the street better than any other color, which is why it's a favorite for mailbox beds and walkways.

  4. 4. Pink and purple garden mums

    Pink and purple garden mum

    Roughly three sold for every four yellow. For customers who want something softer than the classic fall palette, and a popular way to mix up a row of warm colors.

  5. 5. Blue asters

    Blue aster covered in violet-blue blooms

    The best-selling fall plant that isn't a mum, with more than twice the orders of any other non-mum. Violet-blue blooms bring cool color late in the season, their tidy mounded shape sits well next to mums, and they keep drawing butterflies into the first frosts.

    Tip: Asters want full sun to part sun, just like mums, so they can share the same spot.

  6. 6. White garden mums

    White garden mum

    Just behind asters. White is less common than the warm colors, which is exactly why some customers want it. It looks crisp against dark doors and brightens a display of orange and red.

  7. 7. Red ornamental kale

    Red and purple ornamental kale

    Our second-best plant that isn't a mum. Frilly leaves in deep crimson to purple, and the color gets stronger as nights get colder, so kale often looks its best after the mums have peaked.

    Red outsold white kale nearly three to one.

  8. 8. Fall combo planters

    Fall combo planter with mixed autumn annuals

    About one sold for every 35 mums, which is a lot for a premium item. An 11-inch container that mixes fall annuals for color and texture: a finished porch display in one pot, and a popular gift.

    It was our best-selling higher-priced item. One combo planter adds as much to a group's total as several mums, so it's worth offering to supporters who want to give more.

  9. 9. Strawberry begonias

    Strawberry begonia houseplant with trailing runners

    Our best-selling houseplant of the fall. A small, easy-care houseplant with textured leaves and trailing runners that grow baby plants. It's a low-priced add-on, which is why it sells: customers add one to a mum order for a kitchen windowsill.

  10. 10. Spider plant hanging baskets

    Spider plant in a hanging basket

    A close second among houseplants. Fall isn't only for outdoor plants. A spider plant is one of the easiest houseplants to keep, handles a wide range of light, and gives customers something green that lasts all winter.

    Tip: Houseplants give supporters who don't have a porch or yard something to buy.

How we counted: Counted from every completed order, online and paper, in our Fall Mums 2026 season (July to September 2026), across more than 100 Indiana fundraisers. We share rankings and comparisons rather than exact counts. Cancelled and unpaid orders aren't included. When an item sold out and a similar plant was offered in its place, those sales are counted with the plant it replaced.

Just outside the top 10

White ornamental kale, our mums planted in decorative pumpkin pots, and three trailing houseplant baskets: purple passion, lipstick plant and ruby necklace. Every one of them sold well enough to keep.

What this means for your order form

  • Lead with mums in the warm colors. Orange, red and yellow sell themselves.
  • Add one or two plants that aren't mums, like asters or kale, for customers who want variety.
  • Offer one higher-priced item, like a combo planter, for supporters who want to give more.
  • Include a low-priced houseplant for customers without a porch or yard.

Frequently asked questions

When should we run a fall plant fundraiser?

Our fall selling window runs from mid-July to late September, and plants are delivered from late August into early October. Most groups sell for two to three weeks and pick their delivery date when they sign up.

How long do garden mums last?

In full sun with regular watering, a blooming garden mum looks good for several weeks. Plants with some buds still closed will bloom longer. Garden mums are perennials, so planting them in the ground early in the fall gives them the best chance of coming back next year.

Does our group have to pay anything upfront?

No. There's no upfront cost and no minimum order. Customers order online with a card or on a paper order form, and we deliver the plants to your group on your delivery day.

What sells best besides mums?

Blue asters, ornamental kale and fall combo planters, in that order. Easy houseplants like strawberry begonias and spider plants also sold well as low-priced add-ons.