10 Questions to Ask Before You Choose a Fundraising Company
By Hoosier Boy Fundraising · Updated · 4 min read
Most product fundraisers look alike from the outside: a catalog, an order form and a delivery day. The differences that matter, like what your group really keeps, who handles the money and who sorts the boxes, are in the details.
Here are the 10 questions we'd ask any fundraising company, including us. After each one we say how Hoosier Boy handles it, so you have something to compare against.
1. Is there any upfront cost?
Some programs ask you to buy inventory, pay a setup fee or cover printing before you sell anything. That puts your group's money at risk before the first order.
How we do it: there's no upfront cost. You don't pay for anything before you sell.
2. What does our group earn on each item, in writing?
Ask for the price of each item and what your group earns on it before you commit. A vague promise of a "great return" is hard to plan around.
How we do it: ask us for your season's numbers before you sign up. Once you're selling, the Seller Profit Report on your dashboard shows what your group has actually earned, seller by seller.
3. Is there a minimum order or a sales goal?
Minimums can leave a small group stuck paying for what it couldn't sell.
How we do it: no minimum order. A small team and a whole school use the same program.
4. Who handles the money?
Find out where customers' payments go, whether your volunteers have to count cash, and when your group gets paid.
How we do it: customers who order online pay by card through secure checkout, and we send your group its share when the sale wraps up. If you also take paper orders, your group keeps that cash and those checks and pays us for those plants.
5. Can supporters order online and on paper?
Online ordering reaches out-of-town family. Paper still wins at workplaces, church lobbies and grandparents' kitchen tables. You want both.
How we do it: every seller gets a personal link and QR code, and you can print order forms with photos of every plant. Paper orders are entered into your dashboard, so everything ends up in one place.
6. How does the product get to us, and who sorts it?
Delivery day is where fundraisers fall apart. Ask who delivers, where, and how each customer's order is kept straight.
How we do it: we deliver every order to your location on the delivery date you choose. Each customer gets a pickup code and QR ticket by email, and you get printable pickup sheets for every seller.
7. What happens if something arrives damaged?
Live plants, frozen food and baked goods can all have a bad day. Ask what the company does about it before it happens.
How we do it: we grow the plants ourselves, and if anything arrives damaged or doesn't look right, tell us and we'll make it right.
8. How long does the sale run, and who sets the dates?
Too short and sellers don't reach everyone; too long and momentum fades.
How we do it: most groups sell for two to three weeks, and you choose your own selling window and delivery date.
9. What do you need from us before you pay us?
A good company makes the check out to your organization, not a volunteer's personal name. Expect to give your organization's legal name, a mailing address and a tax ID (EIN) if you have one.
How we do it: we ask for those details once, in a short form on your dashboard, so the proceeds go to your organization.
10. Who do we call when we need help?
Find out whether you'll reach a person who knows your fundraiser, or a general support line.
How we do it: our team is in Indianapolis. You can book a call from your dashboard or press "Need help right now?" to reach us.
A quick way to compare
Put the answers from each company side by side. The best fit is usually the one with no upfront cost, clear per-item numbers in writing, both online and paper ordering, and a real delivery-day plan. If you'd like to see how ours works, take the 3-minute tour.
Frequently asked questions
What's the safest kind of fundraiser for a small group?
One with no upfront cost and no minimum order, where customers pay as they order. Then your group never owes money for products it couldn't sell.
Are online fundraisers safe for customers?
They should be. Ask whether card payments go through a well-known processor. Ours go through secure card checkout, and we never see or store card numbers.
Who is Hoosier Boy Fundraising?
The fundraising program of Schlegel Greenhouse, a family greenhouse in Indianapolis growing plants since 1972. Read our FAQ or start a fundraiser.
More fundraising guides
- 10 Tips for Running a Successful Plant FundraiserPractical tips from more than 100 Indiana plant fundraisers: how to pick dates, recruit sellers, use paper and online orders, and run an easy pickup day.
- Top 10 Fall Fundraising Items, Ranked by Real OrdersThe 10 fall fundraiser items customers actually bought most, ranked from real orders across more than 100 Indiana school, church and team fundraisers.
- Spring Flower Fundraiser: 10 Things to Know for 2027Planning a spring flower fundraiser for Mother's Day 2027? Dates, what sells, sun and shade tips, and how a hanging basket sale works from start to finish.