Skip to content

Poinsettia Fundraiser FAQ: 10 Questions Answered

By Hoosier Boy Fundraising · Updated · 3 min read

Poinsettias are the classic holiday fundraiser: everyone decorates in December, and a plant from a local greenhouse beats another tin of popcorn. Here are the 10 questions organizers ask us most about running a poinsettia sale, answered from our own Christmas season.

  1. 1. When does a poinsettia fundraiser run?

    Our Christmas season sells from mid-October to mid-December, and plants are delivered from the week before Thanksgiving through December 21. Most groups sell for two to three weeks and choose a delivery date that lands before their families decorate.

  2. 2. Which colors sell best?

    Speckled red and cream poinsettia

    Red, by a wide margin. In our 2026 season so far, red is followed by speckled (red splashed with cream), then white, salmon and pink. Offer red plus two or three others and you've covered almost every customer.

  3. 3. What sizes are available?

    Our 6-inch poinsettia is the fundraiser favorite. It's sized for a mantel, a table or an entryway and has a price that's easy for supporters to say yes to. We also grow a larger 7.5-inch, four-bloom plant for customers who want a showpiece.

  4. 4. What else sells alongside poinsettias?

    Tricolor Christmas cactus in bloom

    A tricolor Christmas cactus is our second-best Christmas seller this year. Winter porch pots filled with fresh greens and ornaments, holiday bowls and easy houseplants round out the order form and give customers a choice beyond red and white.

  5. 5. How do I keep a poinsettia looking good?

    Bright, indirect light and a normal room temperature. Keep it away from cold drafts, heat vents and fireplaces. Water when the top of the soil feels dry, and don't let the pot sit in water. If it came in a decorative sleeve or foil, poke a hole in the bottom or remove it before watering.

  6. 6. How long do poinsettias last?

    With that care, a poinsettia stays colorful through the holidays and often well into January.

  7. 7. Are poinsettias safe around pets?

    They're not the deadly plant of holiday legend, but chewing the leaves can upset a cat's or dog's mouth and stomach. Keep them out of reach of pets that like to nibble.

  8. 8. How do we protect poinsettias on a cold pickup day?

    Poinsettias are tropical and don't like cold. Keep them sleeved, carry them straight to a warm car, and don't leave them in a cold vehicle while you run errands. Even a short blast of freezing wind can damage the leaves.

    Tip: Ask customers to bring their car to the door and pre-warm it on very cold days.

  9. 9. Can churches order poinsettias for the sanctuary?

    Yes, through our separate church poinsettia program. It's a preorder for churches decorating their own building rather than a fundraiser, and our team confirms every order personally.

  10. 10. How do customers get their poinsettias?

    We deliver your group's whole order to your location on your delivery date, and customers pick up there with the pickup code and QR ticket from their confirmation email. Groups can also choose to have sellers deliver to customers instead.

Ready to plan yours?

See our 10 tips for running a successful plant fundraiser, or start your fundraiser. It takes about five minutes.

Frequently asked questions

Is there an upfront cost for a poinsettia fundraiser?

No. There's no upfront cost and no minimum order with Hoosier Boy. Customers pay as they order, online by card or on a paper order form.

What's the best-selling poinsettia color?

Red. In our 2026 Christmas season it has outsold every other color, followed by speckled red and cream.

When should a school schedule poinsettia delivery?

Early December is popular because families are decorating, but any date from the week before Thanksgiving through December 21 works. Pick a day your volunteers are free for pickup.